DEFIANCE Act: Deepfake Porn Victims Can Sue for $150K+

By Recording Law Editorial Team8 min read
DEFIANCE Act: Deepfake Porn Victims Can Sue for $150K+

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue anonymously under the DEFIANCE Act?

No. You must file the lawsuit (or have your attorney file it) in your name, though your case caption and pleadings may be partially sealed to protect your privacy. The defendant has the right to know who is suing them, but a judge may issue protective orders to limit public disclosure of identifying details.

Do I have to go to criminal court first?

No. The DEFIANCE Act is purely civil. You do not need to file a police report or wait for a criminal prosecution. You sue directly in federal court (or state court; the statute does not limit venue). However, if a criminal case is already underway, evidence from that case may be helpful.

What if the defendant is broke or judgment-proof?

Winning a judgment does not guarantee you'll collect money. If the defendant has no assets or income, collecting can be difficult. However, federal law allows you to garnish wages, place liens on property, and pursue post-judgment enforcement. Many civil plaintiffs use attorneys who work on contingency (taking a percentage of any recovery), so upfront cost is minimal.

Can I sue the platform where the image was posted?

The DEFIANCE Act applies to individuals who produced or distributed the images, not to the platforms themselves. However, the TAKE IT DOWN Act creates platform liability for failure to remove nonconsensual imagery upon notice. Additionally, state laws and emerging civil lawsuits may create platform liability. Consult an attorney for jurisdiction-specific rules.

Is this a criminal law or civil law?

This is purely civil. No one goes to jail under the DEFIANCE Act. If you want criminal charges, that is a separate matter handled by prosecutors, not by victims suing for damages.

What if the deepfake is of a dead person?

The statute protects "identifiable individuals." It is unclear whether estates or surviving family members can sue on behalf of a deceased person. This issue will likely be decided in early cases. Some state laws allow relatives to sue for nonconsensual pornography of the deceased; the DEFIANCE Act may follow that pattern, but the text does not explicitly address it.

How do I prove the image is a deepfake?

You'll likely need expert testimony or forensic analysis showing the image is AI-generated or photoshopped. Digital forensics can detect artifacts, unnatural lighting, or inconsistencies that prove the image is not real. Your attorney will retain an expert to provide evidence at trial or in summary judgment motions.

Can I get injunctions before trial?

Yes. You can request a temporary restraining order (TRO) to stop the defendant from continuing to distribute the image while the case is ongoing. If you win the TRO, it may become a preliminary injunction pending trial, and a permanent injunction if you ultimately prevail. Injunctions are powerful remedies for stopping ongoing harm.

Updates

Initial publication. Senate passed S.1837 unanimously on January 13, 2026. House bill remains stalled despite 10+ bipartisan cosponsors. Paris Hilton and AOC held Capitol press conference January 22, 2026.

Initial publication. Senate passed S.1837 unanimously on January 13, 2026. House bill remains stalled in committee despite bipartisan support. Paris Hilton and AOC held Capitol press conference January 22, 2026, highlighting urgency of deepfake abuse crisis.

Sources and References

  1. S.1837 - 119th Congress (2025-2026): DEFIANCE Act of 2025(congress.gov).gov
  2. Text - S.1837 - 119th Congress (2025-2026): DEFIANCE Act of 2025(congress.gov).gov
  3. Paris Hilton, AOC Advocate for Law Against AI Deepfake Revenge Porn(hollywoodreporter.com)
  4. They sold my pain for clicks: Paris Hilton urges lawmakers to act on nonconsensual deepfakes(19thnews.org)
  5. The TAKE IT DOWN Act: A Federal Law Prohibiting the Nonconsensual Publication of Intimate Images(congress.gov).gov
  6. Deepfake Statistical Data (2023–2025)(views4you.com)
  7. Grok sexual deepfake scandal - Wikipedia(en.wikipedia.org)
Share: